Think ‘Housing Metamorphosis’


I signed up as a faithful community member, to do the right thing, to speak up, to brain-storm and to find answers to what government calls the Housing Elements of our local jurisdictions. I’ve signed up for years and watched the same game, from the same playbook.

Government seeks to meet numbers which are created and derived from regional associations such as AMBAG, i.e., Association of Monterey Bay Area Governments and many with similar handles throughout the State of California that do a numbers crunch and announce that each city and county meet specific numbers and guidelines, all of this done with the ‘best of intentions.’

Those numbers are sometimes astonishingly and seemingly huge and the public outcry often scrubs the numbers down, but not too much because money would be withheld by the State if cities and counties do not comply with those numbers.

Yet, very little housing gets built, so the supply continues to be sparse, especially to those who need it most.

In fact, sometimes the numbers are ‘met’ by using existing housing that is transformed by simply changing the zoning from other uses only to bear a new zoning for housing.

Borrowing from Peter to pay Paul? Double speak? It happens all the time.

We really need to concentrate on building homes/housing that meet all sizes and incomes as a result of careful planning for balanced supply/demand.

Somehow we have created a term called ‘Affordable Housing.’   For years, that term has bothered me because ‘affordable’ is really ‘subsidized’. It is housing that government or developers pay for, with stringent regulations tied to income and price controls—those regulations oft so complex that the rules that govern theiraffordability are like secret, unsolvable cypher.  In my opinion,  we should no longer call these types of programs affordable because they are NOT.

Let’s get real and call it Subsidized Housing, once and for all.

The Housing Elements I signed up, again—to brain-storm about/with, always contain the same critical path, with Associations of Government, and State Housing and Community Development and nothing will change.   It will not change until we recognize the need to alter the old paradigm of using bureaucracies to govern supply. There’s the word: Supply!   That’s what we don’t have.

It will not change until we recognize the need to alter the old paradigm of using bureaucracies to govern supply.

Our zoning refers to multi-residential, but our high density zoning is really very low, compared to other States and (I know I will not be very popular saying this), but some places have created lovely ‘density’ that works! We are terrified of any structure that exceeds three stories. Supply+Density needs to be part of our vocabulary.

What about water? Or, the other argument: We don’t have enough land! I know the arguments, but other places in the world seem to figure it out. We have some of the most brilliant minds in the world living in our area, but somehow it doesn’t matter. Over and over, we keep doing the same thing. We all must be willing to look at other ways of fixing this issue. I’m suggesting that we embrace the idea of creating supply+density, taking into consideration our so-called lack of land, and drought. How long do we continue to ignore saving the rainwater that races to the ocean and considering a better use of the land that helps a community live and thrive? Let’s stop being very much like the famed ostrich whose head is in the sand. Let’s think outside the same, restrictive box! Let’s not keep doing the same things over and over and expecting a different result—oh yes, we know that definition.


Rose Marie McNair is a licensed real estate broker in northern California with over 35 years experience in residential/commercial sales as well as Government Affairs and land use oversight. She has held numerous leadership and legislative roles during her career for local and state organizations including theSanta Cruz Association of Realtors, Pajaro Valley Association of Realtors and the California Association of Realtors (CAR).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.